Psychostick - Why, Oh, Why? Lyrics






I'm looking at you after it's all over
And I don't feel quite the same
That look in your eyes says you don't want me anymore
Even though you are to blame

Why, oh, why did this have to happen
Why did you do me this way

Tell me why
You had to lead me on so long
Tell me why
I had to end it all in song
Tell me why
You ran away with my best friend
Tell me why
I still love you
Love you

Love

I came across an old love letter
And here's what you had to say
Please pick up a gallon of milk while you're shopping at the store

You said I love you so
You're everything to me
I could love no other one
Yeah right

Except for maybe like I said my best friend
And my brother and my dad
And my other brother
And his best friend
And that guy's brother as well
And that one guy who used to come over and mow the lawn every Saturday
Who had a cool tattoo of a dragon on his shoulder and it was really neat and stuff

Tell me why
You slept with everyone but me
Tell me why
I'm out of words that rhyme with me
Tell me why
You still owe me three bucks for that milk
Tell me why
I still love you

Why
Did you leave me alone
Why
In the cold
In the darkness
Why
So I could talk to the walls in the basement
Why
Did you hurt me so bad
Why
Did you feel the remorse
Why
When you broke both of my shins with a crowbar

Tell me why
I still love you
Even though you're a bitch
I still love you
Even though you're a psycho
I still love you
Even though you should die
I still love you





Other Lyrics by Artist

Rand Lyrics

Last Posts

Psychostick Why, Oh, Why? Comments
  1. P.... M....

    AALLLLLLLLLLLLLLLEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  2. W.... ....

    I still love you even though you're a Psychostick.

  3. J.... R....

    Fucking love these guys. I was 16 when this album dropped. I'm now 28 and still singing word for word.

  4. E.... ....

    I think I found an ASMR loose prequel...https://youtu.be/k6L796T20l4

  5. U.... V....

    I'd love if somebody made from this a tab.

    U.... V....

    It's on our website. Psychostick.com

  6. C.... H....

    Alex is the man!

  7. I.... m....

    What key is this in?

  8. R.... M....

    One of the most on point parodies of any band out there (Staind).

  9. V.... M....

    I love how from 0:25 to 0:29 it's the opening chords to "Why, oh, Why?" to the tempo of "Pluh" lmao

  10. N.... ....

    i wish the song had stayed that way at the beginning when alex was playing fast lol

  11. J.... B....

    Alex did not mess it up Pluh

  12. E.... O....

    Was Alex influenced by Lars Ulrich? Just asking

  13. B.... ....

    I can't stop laughing xD

  14. M.... ....

    Fuckin' Alex!

  15. J.... D....

    PSYCHOSTICKKKKK

  16. S.... ....

    Alex can kick Alvin's ass!!

  17. M.... ....

    I swear to god I used to walk to school listening to this album because I looved how it sounds!! But because they're hilarious I used to get weird looks 😂😂😂😂😭😭😭 I'm 24 now

    M.... ....

    I feel this.

  18. K.... P....

    you had one job alex.

  19. N.... ....

    7 exes didn't like this song

  20. P.... D....

    I can relate. also, system of a down must be a massive influence lol

    P.... D....

    +Perry D Haha exactly what i was thinking, this is the closest band i can find similar to soad

  21. B.... ....

    That note got me," Would you please pick up a gallon of milk while your shopping at the store? " T_T

    B.... ....

    BunKnee i daw saw your reply just ask they sang it! LOL

  22. W.... E....

    Your shin bone is the tibia. Fibula is the back part.....

    W.... E....

    William Ewing I mean, if she hit it hard enough it probably still hurt his fibula

    W.... E....

    flyingv96 the shock and the fact that all his weight is on two less bones might make them hurt

  23. J.... C....

    you guys are dope

  24. S.... ....

    I'd be hurt, but I certainly wouldn't love her anymore. I don't take well to betrayal.

    S.... ....

    You'd still care for her in a way, but you'll never fully recover from it. Believe me, I've experienced this with the women that gave me my child and my Mom to my Dad when I was younger. It pains me every day and it's been several years since it happened.

  25. T.... T....

    I was once like this. Still loving a psycho bitch that should die.
    Then i discovered Waffle Fries.
    And i became a bigger and better man.
    ...
    Maybe just bigger.

  26. K.... g....

    Love Love Love Love Love xD

  27. g.... t....

    YOU SLEEPT WITH EVERYONE BUT ME tears of cry xDD

  28. r.... ....

    loved it!

  29. C.... ....

    "I'm out of words that rhyme with "me" "
    Makes me smile every time.

  30. O.... O....

    Awesome Taproot parody :-D

    O.... O....

    Which song is the parody of?

    O.... O....

    Kinda most taproot ballads I think. Cant quite place an exact song though.

    O.... O....

    @oz osborne I only ask because I love Taproot and I don't recall a song sounding like it.

    I do agree though that they're similar in nature, but not enough for me to link them together.

    O.... O....

    I meant it as a parody of style :-D glad you didnt take offence though. I saw taproot on the deftones tour and loved them.

    O.... O....

    @oz osborne Yeah, it's nice to see another Taproot fan. Never got the pleasure of seeing them live... I'm a little jealous. :P

  31. t.... ....

    all I can say is holy shit to this.

  32. L.... A....

    I belive this song is about a xbox who broke.

    L.... A....

    It slept with a bunch of guys?

    L.... A....

    @Nick Deatherage it did yes

    L.... A....

    @Lord Alctim I'm not even mad, I'm impressed.

    L.... A....

    Join the club

  33. N.... S....

    most serious ive heard these guys.... lmfao

  34. P.... ....

    Music Monday! Alex messed this song up at the beginning, but we powered through anyway.

    P.... ....

    My favourite song by you guys, or ever in fact c:

    P.... ....

    this hits a little too close to home... my most recent girlfriend left me for a woman, and a little over a year later, it still hurts at times. you guys really have a song for everything. I've listened to you guys since i was in 5th grade, and i (un(?)fortunately) just found this song. keep on rocking my friends. 

    P.... ....

    Alex made it funny

    P.... ....

    Im sorry I messed it up.

    P.... ....

    Psychostick 22

  35. D.... V....

    At first I was like, wtf Psychostick being serious? :D

    D.... V....

    I dunno, they where pretty serious when I pulled the gun on them 🤷🏻‍♂️

  36. L.... ....

    Alex, should die  NOW !! for the rock shit !

  37. G.... T....

    I still Love You. Even though you should DIE!

  38. a.... m....

    Alex.. Alex. ALEX!

    a.... m....

    This is SLOW song.
    You can do that on the NEXT one...

    a.... m....

    Mitchinatr awwh

  39. A.... B....

    That's not a gasp, that's a sigh.

  40. T.... D....

    prelude to My Clingy Girlfriend...

    T.... D....

    it would make more sense the other way around,she somehow left him,and BAM,new music

  41. D.... ....

    I still love you even though you're a psycho. Wonderful.

  42. A.... W....

    Wow, this guy is hilariously pathetic in this song.

  43. p.... ....

    3 Bucks for milk? Wow

  44. E.... S....

    Why???? Not available on mobile

  45. T.... M....

    why oh why is there less than 250,000 views on this video... you guys are gonna be up near me sept 1st playing with my boys caustic method i'm gonna make it out to that!! cya in Mattydale

  46. D.... M....

    why o why do they never play this song live

  47. m.... ....

    You still owe me three bucks for that milk...

    m.... ....

    musicguy446.hahahahahahaa

    m.... ....

    musicguy446 Again! read this as it was song

  48. F.... ....

    Psychostick, Dethklock, and Steel Panther?

  49. D.... ....

    Waffles!

  50. G.... M....

    would kick ass to see psychostick, dethklok and some other comedy metal super tour

  51. S.... V....

    Damnit Alex!

  52. M.... F....

    I think you can call yourself a genious musicians and comedians, if listeners are laughing at your songs. I laugh)